Ever wondered why some startups seem to attract all the top talent while others struggle to fill key positions? The secret lies in their hiring practices. As a founder, getting your hiring practices right can mean the difference between scaling successfully and burning through your runway with bad hires.
TL;DR: Key Hiring Trends
- Remote-first hiring is becoming the norm, not the exception
- Skills-based hiring is overtaking traditional resume screening
- AI-powered recruitment tools are streamlining the hiring process
- Candidate experience is becoming a major differentiator
- DEI initiatives are shifting from optional to essential
What Are Hiring Practices?
Hiring practices are the strategies and methods organizations use to attract, evaluate, and bring on new team members. For startups, good hiring practices are especially crucial because early employees often become the backbone of your company culture.
The Good: Best Hiring Practices That Actually Work
1. Define Your Mission Before You Hire
Startups that clearly articulate their mission attract candidates who are more likely to stay long-term. Before you post that job listing, make sure you can answer: “Why should talented people want to work here?”
2. Build a Structured Interview Process
Structured interviews are said to be more effective than unstructured ones. Create a standardized process that includes:
- Initial Screening Calls: Use initial calls to assess a candidate’s background, communication skills, and alignment with the role’s basic requirements. Make it a brief, objective conversation to determine if it’s worth moving forward.
- Technical Assessments: Evaluate technical skills through standardized tests or projects relevant to the position. For instance, coding challenges for developers or case studies for product managers can give you a true sense of a candidate’s skills.
- Culture Fit Interviews: Go beyond the resume to see how well candidates align with your startup’s values. Culture fit is vital for startups, where team dynamics can make or break productivity.
- Reference Checks: Speaking with past employers or colleagues gives insight into a candidate’s work style, reliability, and impact in their previous roles. Take the time to verify key details, as it can save you from costly mis-hires.
Discover top interviewing practices and download our sample scorecard for fair candidate evaluation
6 Best Practices for Interviewing Engineers
3. Focus on Skills, Not Just Experience
TestGorilla’s State of Skills-Based Hiring report reveals that 91.2% of companies using skills-based hiring experienced higher retention rates, while 92.5% reported fewer mis-hires. Consider implementing:
- Take-home Projects: Assign real-world projects that reflect the role’s requirements, allowing candidates to showcase their skills on their own time.
- Pair Programming Sessions: For technical roles, consider live coding sessions with existing team members to gauge collaboration and problem-solving skills.
- Role-playing Exercises: For client-facing roles, simulate scenarios like a client call or team presentation to assess communication and adaptability.
- Problem-solving Scenarios: Give candidates a challenge relevant to the role, and observe their approach and creative thinking.
4. Prioritize Diversity from Day One
According to Forbes, since 2013, it has shown that startup and venture investment teams that embrace diversity in gender, race, ethnicity, educational background, and professional experience tend to outperform teams with more homogeneous backgrounds. Make diversity a core part of your hiring practices by:
- Inclusive Job Descriptions: Craft language that appeals to a wide range of applicants. Avoid overly masculine language or excessive requirements that can deter qualified candidates.
- Expand Sourcing Channels: Post openings on platforms known for diverse user bases, such as Jopwell, PowerToFly, and Diversify Tech.
- Implement Blind Resume Screening: Remove identifying details (e.g., names, schools) from resumes to reduce unconscious bias in the early stages.
- Train Interviewers on Bias Awareness: Equip your hiring team with the knowledge to recognize and mitigate biases, creating a fairer process for everyone.
Learn how to build and retain diverse talent
How to Recruit a Diverse Engineering Team
The Bad: Hiring Practices to Avoid
1. Rushing the Process
Don’t let pressure to fill positions quickly lead to poor choices. A rushed hire can lead to wasted resources, time, and a dip in team morale. Instead, prioritize quality by setting realistic timelines and sticking to a well-thought-out process.
2. Overselling the Role
While it might seem advantageous to “sell” the role to candidates, setting unrealistic expectations can backfire. Paint an honest picture of the role, including the challenges and growth opportunities, to attract people who will stick around.
3. Ignoring Red Flags
When you’re eager to fill a role, it’s easy to overlook minor concerns. Take red flags seriously, as small issues can escalate into major problems down the line.
Making Your Hiring Practices Work
Create a Clear Hiring Roadmap
Start with these steps:
- Document Your Hiring Process: Clearly outline each stage, including screening, interviews, assessments, and reference checks.
- Define Role Requirements Clearly: Specify the skills, experience, and attributes needed, so your team has a shared understanding of what you’re looking for.
- Create Standardized Evaluation Criteria: Develop a scoring system or checklist to compare candidates fairly and objectively.
- Establish Communication Protocols: Set up regular communication touchpoints to keep candidates engaged and informed throughout the process.
- Set Up Onboarding Procedures: Don’t wait until the offer is signed to think about onboarding; a strong start helps new hires become productive faster.
Leverage Technology Wisely
Modern hiring practices increasingly rely on tech tools. Consider:
- Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS): Centralize candidate information and track their journey through your hiring pipeline.
- Video Interviewing Platforms: Conduct interviews with candidates who are remote or have limited availability, ensuring you’re not losing out on great talent due to logistics.
- Skills Assessment Software: Evaluate candidates’ abilities with software tools like Codility or HackerRank for technical assessments.
- Reference Checking Tools: Platforms like Checkster or SkillSurvey can provide automated reference checks, saving you time while providing quality insights.
Best Practices for Remote Hiring
With remote work here to stay, adapt your hiring practices:
- Use Asynchronous Communication Tools: Tools like Slack, Asana, or Trello help keep remote teams in sync without relying on real-time communication.
- Implement Virtual Culture Fit Assessments: Get creative with virtual team-building exercises or use scenarios to see how well a candidate meshes with your remote culture.
- Create Digital Onboarding Experiences: From welcome videos to online training modules, build a strong onboarding plan that sets up remote hires for success.
- Build Remote-first Documentation: Document policies, workflows, and project guidelines to ensure everyone has access to critical information, regardless of their location.
Measuring Success
Track these metrics to evaluate your hiring practices:
- Time-to-Hire: Measures the efficiency of your hiring process. Find the balance between speed and quality.
- Quality of Hire: Assess performance, retention, and feedback to determine if new hires meet expectations.
- Cost per Hire: Helps you understand the financial efficiency of your hiring practices. Consider all costs, including recruiting fees, tech tools, and time spent.
- Offer Acceptance Rate: If candidates regularly turn down offers, investigate whether compensation, role clarity, or other factors need adjustment.
- New Hire Retention Rate: Indicates if you’re hiring candidates who are a good fit for your company and helps assess your onboarding effectiveness.
Additional Insights:
Interview Questions to Ask Technical Talent for Your Startup
The Most Effective Interview Process for Hiring Engineers
Tech Hiring Trends for Startups
The Bottom Line
The best hiring practices aren’t about finding perfect candidates – they’re about building a system that consistently identifies people who can grow with your company. Start small, measure what works, and adapt as you learn.
