Data Engineer vs Data Scientist vs ML Engineer: Which One Do You Actually Need First

Choosing between a Data Engineer, Data Scientist, and ML Engineer can feel like three different bets on the same runway. Each role solves a distinct bottleneck, yet early-stage founders often group them together and risk an expensive mis-hire.
In this guide, you will see clear year-one cost benchmarks, a quick decision tree, and interview rubrics that map each role to a concrete business goal. Read on to learn how a Data Engineer steadies your pipelines, how a Data Scientist drives product insights, and how an ML Engineer turns models into real-time features so you can hire in the right order and keep cash burn predictable.
Year-One Cost Benchmarks
Before you fall in love with a job description, verify your budget. The median U.S. base salary for each role is listed below, based on Built In’s May 2025 data. Add about 20 percent for payroll taxes, benefits, and stock options to calculate the true Year-1 cash cost.
Role | Avg US Base Pay | Estimated Year-1 Cash* |
---|---|---|
Data Engineer | $125k | ~$150k |
Data Scientist | $127k | ~$153k |
ML Engineer | $158k | ~$190k |
*Cash = base + typical payroll costs, not equity.
The 5-Minute Decision Tree
Step | Ask Yourself → | If No → Hire | If Yes → Go to |
---|---|---|---|
1. Data Foundations | “Do we already have a trusted cloud warehouse with pipelines that run without babysitting? | Hire a Data Engineer | Step 2 |
2. Insights for Humans | “Are product or growth teams blocked by unanswered questions, cohort cuts, or A/B tests?” | Hire a Data Scientist | Step 3 |
3. ML in the Product | “Will customers interact with an ML-powered feature in the next 3–6 months?” | Hire an ML Engineer | You are done; revisit later |
How to Use the Decision Tree
- Start at Step 1.
- Answer honestly. If your answer is No, that row shows the role you need first.
- Stop there. Hire, onboard, and let that person unblock the next stage.
- Re-run the tree every fund-raise or major roadmap shift.
Why This Order Works
- First, stable pipelines give every metric a single source of truth.
- Next, insights drive roadmap choices and fund-raise decks.
- Finally, production models add real-time magic only after data and analytics run smoothly.
Run the tree, hire with intent, and keep your runway intact.
Role Cheat Sheets
Data Engineer Responsibilities
A Data Engineer is your pipeline builder. They pull raw data from every app you use, clean it, and load it into a central warehouse like Snowflake or BigQuery. Using tools such as Airflow for scheduling and Terraform for infrastructure, they automate the entire flow and add testing frameworks (dbt, Great Expectations) so bad data never reaches the team.
Interview mini-rubric
Skill to Confirm | Ask About | Test |
---|---|---|
SQL mastery | Window functions, CTEs | Clean up a tangled query live |
Cloud know-how | IAM roles, VPC basics | Sketch a secure ingestion path |
Observability | Metrics vs. logs vs. traces | Walk through a failed job RCA |
Data Scientist Responsibilities
A Data Scientist turns clean data into decisions. Working in notebooks, they run A/B tests, slice cohorts, and build forecasting or classification models. Their main output is insight in plain language, often supported by charts, that guides product and growth teams.
Interview mini-rubric
Skill to Confirm | Ask About | Test |
---|---|---|
Stats intuition | Power, p-values, Bayesian vs. frequentist | Spot errors in an A/B design |
Storytelling | Turning data into action | Pitch a 5-slide insight deck |
Tool fluency | Pandas / Polars / Plotly | Code an exploratory analysis |
Machine Learning Engineer Responsibilities
A Machine Learning Engineer takes the Data Scientist’s model and makes it part of your product. They package the model in a service, deploy it behind an API, and monitor its performance in real time. They also handle CI/CD, cost tuning, and rollback plans to keep predictions fast, cheap, and reliable.
Interview mini-rubric
Skill to Confirm | Ask About | Test |
---|---|---|
Deployment depth | Canary, blue-green, shadow traffic | Diagram a zero-downtime rollout |
MLOps mindset | Drift, decay, data contracts | Choose health metrics post-launch |
Coding rigor | Tests and refactors | Tidy a spaghetti model script |
Founder FAQ
Q: Can one unicorn handle it all?
Early on, yes. A senior data generalist can keep the lights on across engineering, analytics, and ML. However, market data compiled by Live Data Technologies and analyzed by Data Career Jumpstart shows that the average tenure for Data Engineers, Data Scientists, and related roles is only about 18 months. After that, most “unicorns” move on, forcing teams to rebuild knowledge from scratch.
Q: Contractor or full-time?
Need quick help clearing data stuck in different apps? Hire a contractor. Pay only for the hours you use. You can start fast, scale time up or down, and avoid payroll taxes or equity. Downsides: costs rise if the work grows, and contractors rarely build long-term product know-how.
If data work will be ongoing, bring the role in-house. You gain someone who owns the architecture and grows with the company.
Rule of thumb: Use a contractor for short, defined projects; hire full-time when data engineering is core to the roadmap.
Q: Where do VCs stand?
Andreessen Horowitz’s report stresses that investors now look for solid data plumbing before flashy models. The market is consolidating around warehouses, lakehouses, and reliable pipelines; only after that foundation is in place do they expect ML features. In short, clean pipelines first, models later.
Key Takeaways for Hiring Teams
- Match the hire to the bottleneck. Fix data plumbing first with a Data Engineer, unlock product insights next with a Data Scientist, then tackle real-time features with an ML Engineer.
- Use lean interview rubrics. Focus on three core signals per role to avoid drawn-out loops and keep offers consistent.
- Re-run the decision tree often. Check it after every fundraise or major roadmap shift so hiring stays aligned with priorities.
Need a Hand? Hire with Kofi Group
If you’d rather skip the guesswork, Kofi Group can surface pre-vetted Data Engineers, Data Scientists, and ML Engineers who fit your stage, stack, and budget. We run the technical screens, and deliver a short list so you can make the right hire in weeks, not months.
Ready to move fast?
Reach out to Kofi Group and receive a curated shortlist of active and passive candidates within 14 days.
For More Insights:
Share This Blog
Kofi Group has helped 100+ startups hire software and machine learning engineers. Will fill most of the roles we recruit on with 5 or less candidates presented.
Contact us today to start building your dream team!